BMW i3 vs Mercedes C-Class Electric over 581 miles: how much of the official range survived
What Car? drove a BMW i3 50 xDrive and a Mercedes C 400 4MATIC Electric from London to Land's End and back. Here is the real-world range they saw at 8–12°C, how the charging stops went, and how far the official figures still are.

British magazine What Car? took two newly launched electric executive saloons, a BMW i3 50 xDrive and a Mercedes C 400 4MATIC Electric, from the London area to Land's End in Cornwall and back again. The route was 581 miles (935 km) over two days. This is not a test by the “Mașina Timpului” channel: the video, published on 10 November, belongs to What Car?, and the drivers were Will Nightingale and John Howell.
The figures below are their observations, not ours. We checked the official specifications with BMW Group and Mercedes-Benz.
The cars on the trip
The new i3 has nothing to do with the city-sized i3 that arrived in 2013. It is, in effect, an electric 3 Series on the Neue Klasse platform. The 50 xDrive in this test has all-wheel drive, 345 kW (469 hp) and a 108.7 kWh usable battery. BMW quotes a WLTP range of up to 912 km (567 miles) and DC charging at up to 400 kW, with 10–80% in 21 minutes. In the UK, What Car? cites a starting price of £53,425 for the 50 xDrive. The test car, an M Sport First Edition with 20-inch wheels and options, came to just over £63,000, and its official range dropped, the magazine said, to 534 miles.
The C 400 4MATIC Electric is the launch version of the new electric C-Class: two motors, 360 kW, a two-speed gearbox on the rear axle and a 94 kWh usable battery on an 800 V architecture. Mercedes quotes a WLTP range of up to 762 km. On the official UK site, the same model is listed at up to 452 miles and from £57,995. What Car? says the car in the test was a Premier Edition with air suspension, rear-wheel steering and 20-inch wheels, priced at £75,495, with its official range reduced to 428 miles. Official charging: up to 330 kW and 22 minutes from 10 to 80%.
What Car? also wanted a Tesla Model 3 as a benchmark, but says Tesla told them that, that week, it had no cars left in the UK, including press cars. A follow-up test against the Model 3 is promised later. We could not independently verify Tesla's UK stock, so that claim stays with the magazine.
Day one: 285 miles to Land's End
The first leg was 285 miles, from Cobham Services to Land's End, mostly on the motorway. The i3 arrived with 26% charge and 116 miles indicated. The Mercedes arrived with 18% and 62 miles indicated. Both covered the distance on a single charge without drama, though the BMW clearly had more in reserve.
At the 200-mile mark, Nightingale noted some wind noise around the i3's front pillars and a bit of suspension noise, but a composed motorway gait. Howell, in the C-Class, described a quieter car that wafted along on its air suspension, even on a coarse surface.
Real-world range and the cost of the trip
On the second day they stopped to charge after 318 miles. The i3 still had 14% left, which What Car? extrapolated to a maximum range of 369 miles. The Mercedes was down to 4%, so 331 miles. The temperature was 8–12°C, so this was not a summer test.
Against the official figures for the cars as tested, the BMW fell 31% short of WLTP and the Mercedes 23%. In absolute terms the i3 still went farther, but the Mercedes got closer to its own claim.
Over the full 581 miles, the i3 took 183.8 kWh from the grid and the Mercedes 185.4 kWh. Including charging losses, real-world efficiency was 3.16 miles/kWh for the BMW (about 19.7 kWh/100 km) and 3.13 miles/kWh for the Mercedes (about 19.9 kWh/100 km). The trip computers were a little more optimistic: 3.5 and 3.4 miles/kWh respectively.
At 79p/kWh, the public charging rate they paid, the trip cost £145.13 in the BMW and £146.50 in the Mercedes. If the final top-up, at the destination, had been done at home at 26p/kWh (the UK energy price cap at the time), the totals would have fallen to £93.86 and £95.91. The cost gap is, in practice, negligible.
Charging: the brochure figures, and what the plug actually delivered
They stopped at a Fastned site in Camborne, with six stalls rated at 300 kW and only one other customer. The batteries had been preconditioned, and both cars were reporting that they could have accepted more power than the site was delivering.
- i3: 14 to 90% in 47 minutes, at an average of 110 kW; the 20–80% slice took 38 minutes and 2 seconds, against BMW's official 21 minutes for 10–80%.
- Mercedes: 20 to 80% in 39 minutes and 20 seconds; 4 to 90% in 56 minutes, at an average of 95.8 kW, against the official 22 minutes for 10–80%.
The team's conclusion will sound familiar to anyone who uses public chargers often: on paper both cars can charge very quickly, but in the real world you often wait longer, even when the site is quiet. Those official 21- or 22-minute times need a stall that really can hold 330–400 kW, not just one labelled “rapid”.
Boots, space and their verdict
Officially, the Mercedes has a 470-litre boot and the BMW a 420-litre boot plus a 31-litre frunk. In What Car?'s suitcase test, each car swallowed seven cases in the main boot. The Mercedes also took one in a frunk the testers measured at 101 litres; the BMW's frunk was too small for a case. In the back, both felt tight for tall adults.
On comfort, the magazine is clear: in the forms tested, the C-Class wins on ride, quietness and equipment, almost like a junior S-Class. The i3 is cheaper, has more range and, on paper, charges faster. For What Car?, in these specifications, the Mercedes came out ahead, but the i3 remains “an incredibly good car”, and the cheaper 40 xDrive (officially up to 710 km / 441 miles WLTP, with an 82.8 kWh battery) could tip the balance the other way. Mercedes also has a rear-wheel-drive version on the way, quoted at around 500 miles officially.
A Tesla Model 3 still sits in the background. What Car?'s favourite version costs around £45,000 in the UK, so far less, and officially out-ranges the launch C-Class, with the Supercharger network on top. That, though, is the subject of the next test, not this one.
What it means for drivers
- Official range is a ceiling, not a day-to-day promise. On a long, cool autumn trip at 8–12°C, both cars delivered 23–31% less than WLTP. Even so, more than 300 real-world miles on a charge is still a serious figure for a family saloon.
- Brochure charging speeds only count if the stall keeps up. With warm batteries and nearly empty 300 kW posts, average rates were around 96–110 kW. On a long journey, budget 40–50 minutes, not 20.
- Efficiency was almost identical. The BMW went farther mainly because its battery is larger, not because it uses dramatically less energy.
- Price is still the i3's strongest card, at least in the UK, where the 50 xDrive starts clearly below the C 400. Buyers who want the Mercedes' limousine-like comfort pay for it, especially in the top trims. List prices and lead times in other markets will not match the UK figures, so they need checking locally before you compare deals.


